The short answer to can I sue my employer for a work injury in Vermont is usually no, because Vermont's workers' compensation system is set up as the exclusive remedy, meaning you trade the right to sue for guaranteed medical and wage benefits regardless of fault. But that rule is not absolute. If your employer intentionally hurt you, did not carry workers' comp insurance, or a third party like a subcontractor or equipment maker caused your injury, you may have grounds for a civil claim on top of or instead of a comp claim. Which category your injury falls into changes what you can recover and who you can go after, so it pays to look closely at how the injury actually happened before you assume comp is your only option.
Table of Contents
Why Workers Comp Usually Blocks a Lawsuit
When You Can Sue Instead of Filing Comp
What Proof You Need Before Filing a Claim
Why Workers Comp Usually Blocks a Lawsuit
Vermont built its comp system as a swap: you give up the right to sue your employer in court, and in exchange you get benefits without having to prove anyone did anything wrong. That trade applies no matter who caused the accident, including your own mistake on the job. It's why most injured workers in Springfield, Rutland, or Burlington file a comp claim instead of a lawsuit.
Comp pays your medical bills and a portion of your lost wages, but it doesn't pay for pain and suffering the way a lawsuit might. The exclusive remedy rule holds even when your employer ignored a safety rule, skipped a required inspection, or knew about a hazard and did nothing. That might feel unfair, but Vermont law treats it as the cost of a system built for speed and certainty rather than fault-finding.
Workers comp: paid regardless of fault, covers medical and partial wages
Lawsuit: requires proving fault, can cover pain and suffering
Comp: no court, faster payout, capped benefits
Lawsuit: court process, slower, no cap on damages
When You Can Sue Instead of Filing Comp
You can sue your employer directly in a few specific situations that remove the comp shield entirely. The first is intentional harm, meaning your employer deliberately hurt you rather than just acting carelessly. The second is a missing comp policy; if your employer never carried the required workers comp insurance, you're free to sue in civil court for full damages.
A third path runs alongside your comp claim rather than replacing it. If someone other than your employer caused your injury, a subcontractor who left a hazard, an equipment manufacturer who sold a defective tool, or a driver on the job site, you can often file a third-party claim against them while still collecting comp benefits.
Check if your employer intentionally caused the injury, not just acted negligently
Confirm whether your employer actually carried workers comp coverage at the time
Identify any outside party, like a subcontractor or supplier, whose actions contributed
Keep your comp claim moving even if you're also pursuing a third-party case
What Proof You Need Before Filing a Claim
Building a case outside comp takes documentation, not just your account of what happened. Start with anything in writing that shows you reported an unsafe condition before you got hurt, like an email, a text, or a safety complaint form. That paper trail can show your employer knew about the risk and chose to ignore it.
If you're arguing your employer had no comp coverage, you'll need proof of that gap, which the Vermont Department of Labor can confirm. You also want an incident report, names of coworkers who saw what happened, photos of the job site, and medical records that tie your injury directly to that event.
Written safety complaints or reports made before the injury
Confirmation of missing workers comp coverage, if that applies
Incident report, witness names, and job site photos
Medical records linking the injury to the specific workplace event
Pay stubs or employment records showing your work status at the time
A free case evaluation with our office at 56 Main Street, Suite 303 in Springfield can help you sort out which documents actually matter for your situation.
Deciding Whether to File Comp or Pursue a Claim
Before you sign anything or let a deadline pass, get a second set of eyes on your injury. Brady / Donahue gives free case evaluations to hurt workers across Vermont and New Hampshire, and that conversation can catch an exception you'd never spot alone, like an uninsured employer or a third party who shares the blame. Comp deadlines and evidence fade fast, so call before you decide anything, not after.
Common Questions About Suing an Employer
Will I lose my workers comp benefits if I try to sue my employer?
Trying is not the problem, but filing a lawsuit your case does not qualify for can stall your comp payments while the issue gets sorted out. If you have an intentional harm claim, a missing coverage situation, or a third-party defendant, those paths can run without touching your comp benefits. A free case evaluation with Brady / Donahue can tell you which one actually fits before you risk anything.
What if my employer pressures me not to report the injury at all?
Report the injury anyway, in writing, even if your employer tells you not to bother. Vermont law requires employers to report workplace injuries, and pressuring you to skip that step can itself be evidence of bad faith if your claim gets disputed later. Send an email or text describing the injury and keep a copy for yourself.
Can I sue a coworker instead of my employer for causing my injury?
Usually not. The same exclusive remedy rule that blocks suits against your employer also covers coworkers, with limited exceptions. The law does allow so-called, co-employee claims under limited circumstances. One such limited exception is where a co-workers is driving a vehicle on the job and is covered by their own separate insurance. In these instances, a separate third-party claim can be brought against the co-worker and their insurance company.
Related articles
How Vermont Workers Compensation Works for Injured Employees
What to Do if Your Vermont Workers Comp Claim Is Denied
Vermont Personal Injury Statute of Limitations Explained
John Brady has many years of litigation and trial experience in state and federal courts. He has tried numerous cases to jury verdict, and countless other cases which have resolved short of verdict, and has been lead counsel on 21 appeals. John has been practicing law since 1991, initially in Boston, Massachusetts and since 1993 primarily in Vermont and New Hampshire.Contact John: jbrady@bradydonahue.com
Ph: 802-885-2001 ext. 302

